native arenas audited
World Arena audit
Winners still need verification.
This page explains World Arena guardrails: low trades, extreme returns, near-perfect survival and the path from candidate to promotable.
strategy × arena rows
items to review before promotion
Promotion Rules
Candidate
The strategy exists in the arena but does not have enough evidence for promotion yet.
Needs review
Low trades, extreme return or drawdown review. Interesting result, not production-ready yet.
Promotable
Positive alpha, enough trades, acceptable drawdown and solid Conquest Score in the snapshot.
Checks
| Check | Status | Severity | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|
| native_assets_present | pass | info | 9 native World Arena assets detected. |
| strategy_rows_present | pass | info | 195 total strategy rows across native arenas. |
| native_roster_balance | warning | medium | Native roster sizes range from 9 to 72; BTC can dominate comparisons if not labeled separately. |
| champion_metric_completeness | warning | medium | Champion metrics need review for: bitcoin. |
| champion_trade_count | warning | medium | Champions below 20 trades: cac40, dax, eurusd, oil, silver. |
| extreme_return_review | warning | medium | Extreme champion returns need OOS/period review: silver. |
| champion_reproducibility_artifacts | pass | info | Every native champion exposes strategy parameters and an equity curve. |
| state_cache_alignment | warning | high | Current cache and saved state Buy & Hold differ by more than 1 point for: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, silver, sp500. |
| hospital_threshold_review | warning | medium | Many arenas show near-100% survival: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, sp500. |
Arenas to Review
| Asset | Champion | Alpha | Trades | Flags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin | Deep Shadow | +38.49 | 40 | drawdown_zero_or_missing |
| CAC 40 | GA CAC 40 Momentum | +27.21 | 13 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchlow_trade_count_under_20all_or_nearly_all_survived |
| DAX | GA DAX Conquest | +17.13 | 18 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchlow_trade_count_under_20all_or_nearly_all_survived |
| EUR/USD | GA EUR/USD Momentum | +2.15 | 8 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchlow_trade_count_under_20all_or_nearly_all_survived |
| Gold | GA Gold Mean Reversion | +28.80 | 28 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchall_or_nearly_all_survived |
| Nasdaq 100 | Nasdaq 100 Buy & Hold | +0.00 | 0 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchall_or_nearly_all_survivedno_strategy_beats_buy_hold |
| Oil | Oil Trend Conquest v2 | +20.58 | 7 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchlow_trade_count_under_20all_or_nearly_all_survived |
| Silver | GA Silver Robust | +50.55 | 16 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchlow_trade_count_under_20extreme_return_requires_oos_review |
| S&P 500 | S&P 500 Buy & Hold | +0.00 | 0 | state_cache_buy_hold_mismatchall_or_nearly_all_survivedno_strategy_beats_buy_hold |