{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"Dataset","name":"World Arena Validation Audit","description":"Machine-readable sanity checks for Strategy Arena World Arena native market results.","url":"https://strategyarena.io/facts/world-arena-validation-audit.json","license":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","creator":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Strategy Arena","url":"https://strategyarena.io"},"dateModified":"2026-10-16T21:37:01.544657+00:00","isAccessibleForFree":true,"inLanguage":["en","fr"],"stats":{"assets_total":9,"world_rows_total":198,"checks_total":9,"warnings_total":5,"status":"warning","last_update_iso":"2026-10-16T21:37:01.544657+00:00"},"facts":[{"key":"audit_scope","value":"This audit checks structure and obvious metric risks; it does not prove profitability or future performance.","source":"https://strategyarena.io/facts/world-arena-validation-audit.json"},{"key":"next_backtest_requirement","value":"High-performing native champions should be reviewed with out-of-sample windows, fees, slippage, drawdown and trade count before promotion.","source":"https://strategyarena.io/methodology"}],"not_claimed":["Not investment advice.","Paper trading only.","No guaranteed returns."],"see_also":["https://strategyarena.io/facts/world-arena.json","https://strategyarena.io/world-arena","https://strategyarena.io/validated-tradingview-strategies","https://strategyarena.io/methodology"],"checks":[{"key":"native_assets_present","status":"pass","severity":"info","detail":"9 native World Arena assets detected."},{"key":"strategy_rows_present","status":"pass","severity":"info","detail":"198 total strategy rows across native arenas."},{"key":"native_roster_balance","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Native roster sizes range from 9 to 75; BTC can dominate comparisons if not labeled separately."},{"key":"champion_metric_completeness","status":"pass","severity":"info","detail":"Champion drawdown/identity fields are present for every asset."},{"key":"champion_trade_count","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Champions below 20 trades: cac40, dax, eurusd, oil, silver."},{"key":"extreme_return_review","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Extreme champion returns need OOS/period review: silver."},{"key":"champion_reproducibility_artifacts","status":"pass","severity":"info","detail":"Every native champion exposes strategy parameters and an equity curve."},{"key":"state_cache_alignment","status":"warning","severity":"high","detail":"Current cache and saved state Buy & Hold differ by more than 1 point for: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, silver, sp500."},{"key":"hospital_threshold_review","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Many arenas show near-100% survival: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, sp500."}],"warnings":[{"key":"native_roster_balance","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Native roster sizes range from 9 to 75; BTC can dominate comparisons if not labeled separately."},{"key":"champion_trade_count","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Champions below 20 trades: cac40, dax, eurusd, oil, silver."},{"key":"extreme_return_review","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Extreme champion returns need OOS/period review: silver."},{"key":"state_cache_alignment","status":"warning","severity":"high","detail":"Current cache and saved state Buy & Hold differ by more than 1 point for: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, silver, sp500."},{"key":"hospital_threshold_review","status":"warning","severity":"medium","detail":"Many arenas show near-100% survival: cac40, dax, eurusd, gold, nasdaq, oil, sp500."}],"assets":[{"asset":"Bitcoin","slug":"bitcoin","native_strategies":75,"winning_strategies":15,"cashlike_strategies":6,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":36,"survival_rate":68.0,"hostility":32.0,"buy_hold_return":-6.76,"champion":{"strategy":"Hermes Supervisor","return":17.25,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":24.01,"drawdown":3.15,"sharpe":0.0,"trades":0,"conquest_score":73.9,"reproducible":false,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":false},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":null,"current_cache_bh_return":-26.22,"state_cache_bh_return":null,"buy_hold_delta_points":null,"cache_matches_state":true},"flags":[],"status":"pass"},{"asset":"CAC 40","slug":"cac40","native_strategies":12,"winning_strategies":8,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":5,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":8.19,"champion":{"strategy":"GA CAC 40 Momentum","return":35.4,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":27.21,"drawdown":7.14,"sharpe":1.69,"trades":13,"conquest_score":90.0,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T14:00:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":3.57,"state_cache_bh_return":8.35,"buy_hold_delta_points":4.78,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","low_trade_count_under_20","all_or_nearly_all_survived"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"DAX","slug":"dax","native_strategies":12,"winning_strategies":6,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":4,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":5.25,"champion":{"strategy":"GA DAX Conquest","return":22.38,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":17.13,"drawdown":5.67,"sharpe":1.24,"trades":18,"conquest_score":74.0,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T12:00:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":7.76,"state_cache_bh_return":5.41,"buy_hold_delta_points":2.35,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","low_trade_count_under_20","all_or_nearly_all_survived"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"EUR/USD","slug":"eurusd","native_strategies":11,"winning_strategies":2,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":2,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":-0.13,"champion":{"strategy":"GA EUR/USD Momentum","return":2.02,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":2.15,"drawdown":1.55,"sharpe":0.31,"trades":8,"conquest_score":48.6,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-16T02:00:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":-3.3,"state_cache_bh_return":0.02,"buy_hold_delta_points":3.32,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","low_trade_count_under_20","all_or_nearly_all_survived"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"Gold","slug":"gold","native_strategies":29,"winning_strategies":18,"cashlike_strategies":4,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":7,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":26.46,"champion":{"strategy":"GA Gold Mean Reversion","return":55.26,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":28.8,"drawdown":6.1,"sharpe":2.46,"trades":28,"conquest_score":97.8,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T19:30:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":-3.02,"state_cache_bh_return":26.65,"buy_hold_delta_points":29.67,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","all_or_nearly_all_survived"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"Nasdaq 100","slug":"nasdaq","native_strategies":9,"winning_strategies":9,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":0,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":38.88,"champion":{"strategy":"Nasdaq 100 Buy & Hold","return":38.88,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":0.0,"drawdown":12.05,"sharpe":1.56,"trades":0,"conquest_score":63.8,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T19:30:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":24.98,"state_cache_bh_return":39.09,"buy_hold_delta_points":14.11,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","all_or_nearly_all_survived","no_strategy_beats_buy_hold"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"Oil","slug":"oil","native_strategies":11,"winning_strategies":11,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":1,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":53.7,"champion":{"strategy":"Oil Trend Conquest v2","return":74.28,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":20.58,"drawdown":13.89,"sharpe":1.62,"trades":7,"conquest_score":84.6,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T19:30:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":94.42,"state_cache_bh_return":53.93,"buy_hold_delta_points":40.49,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","low_trade_count_under_20","all_or_nearly_all_survived"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"Silver","slug":"silver","native_strategies":29,"winning_strategies":22,"cashlike_strategies":4,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":5,"survival_rate":72.4,"hostility":27.6,"buy_hold_return":91.55,"champion":{"strategy":"GA Silver Robust","return":142.1,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":50.55,"drawdown":12.16,"sharpe":2.6,"trades":16,"conquest_score":95.5,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T19:30:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":5.68,"state_cache_bh_return":91.84,"buy_hold_delta_points":86.16,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","low_trade_count_under_20","extreme_return_requires_oos_review"],"status":"warning"},{"asset":"S&P 500","slug":"sp500","native_strategies":10,"winning_strategies":9,"cashlike_strategies":0,"strategies_beating_buy_hold":0,"survival_rate":100.0,"hostility":0.0,"buy_hold_return":24.88,"champion":{"strategy":"S&P 500 Buy & Hold","return":24.88,"alpha_vs_buy_hold":0.0,"drawdown":9.18,"sharpe":1.46,"trades":0,"conquest_score":58.7,"reproducible":true,"has_equity_curve":true,"has_strategy_params":true},"cache_audit":{"state_period_end":"2026-06-15T19:30:00+00:00","current_cache_bh_return":16.09,"state_cache_bh_return":25.07,"buy_hold_delta_points":8.98,"cache_matches_state":false},"flags":["state_cache_buy_hold_mismatch","all_or_nearly_all_survived","no_strategy_beats_buy_hold"],"status":"warning"}],"citation_passages":["Strategy Arena publishes a World Arena validation audit to keep structural caveats visible alongside rankings.","The World Arena validation audit flags low trade counts, extreme returns, near-100% survival rates and missing champion metrics for review.","World Arena validation audit data is paper-trading research and should not be interpreted as investment advice or guaranteed performance."]}