Skip to main content
← Back to Minds
🐢

Richard Dennis & William Eckhardt

USA, 1980s
The "Turtles": can trading be taught? (1983)
Pantheon: wave 2Judged by the Lab

THE IDEA

In 1983, Dennis and Eckhardt trained beginners with written rules: buy the breakout of the 20-day high (system 1) or 55-day high (system 2), exit at the break of the 10- or 20-day low, stop at twice the volatility, size set by risk.

WHAT THE THEORY REALLY PROMISES

Rare big trends pay for many small losses, on a diversified portfolio of futures.

JUDGED BY THE LAB ON UNSEEN YEARS

MarketUnseen periodVerdictRule / buy-and-holdMax drawdown rule / buy-and-holdProof
AUD/USD (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period; Deflated Sharpe below 50%)-37.0% / -21.2%50.2% / 47.8%SAP-9331c1d0a12b
EUR/USD (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period; Deflated Sharpe below 50%)-28.1% / -23.8%48.0% / 39.9%SAP-36e1c240bcf0
GBP/USD (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-53.5% / -33.4%58.3% / 47.3%SAP-a8da000c5765
USD/CAD (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period; Deflated Sharpe below 50%)-55.3% / +43.4%58.5% / 27.3%SAP-a146def82f8a
USD/CHF (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-54.0% / -25.9%58.6% / 40.4%SAP-079ece1b0595
USD/JPY (S1 20/10)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-40.5% / +43.6%50.9% / 31.5%SAP-27cc6789cb8f
AUD/USD (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period; Deflated Sharpe below 50%)-25.0% / -21.2%45.3% / 47.8%SAP-035c6c0ee3ef
EUR/USD (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (Deflated Sharpe below 50%)+8.0% / -23.8%28.0% / 39.9%SAP-b8a2bfb937f8
GBP/USD (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-32.6% / -33.4%42.2% / 47.3%SAP-a957ae453110
USD/CAD (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period; Deflated Sharpe below 50%)-43.5% / +43.4%48.7% / 27.3%SAP-c10f6798067d
USD/CHF (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-28.3% / -25.9%46.1% / 40.4%SAP-f5a6743b89e3
USD/JPY (S2 55/20)2008-01 → 2026-10 (18.7 y)No proof of an edge (a loss on the unseen period)-19.2% / +43.6%25.5% / 31.5%SAP-68099bf0d32a

What the theory brings, measured. The Turtle rules played one currency at a time, without unit pyramiding or filter, lose in 11 of the 12 proofs over 18.7 unseen years (since 2008). The 55/20 system on EUR/USD does better than buy-and-hold (+8.0% vs -23.8%), without the gap being distinguishable from luck. The legend rested on dozens of futures markets and full risk management: the breakout alone is not the system. What the measure gives back to the Turtles: their rules were written down, hence judgeable, which is still rare.

Rule written and preregistered on 12/10/2026, before any proof, with its source's parameters; one trial per market, nothing tuned; judged in certified mode by Lab 270, which cuts the unseen period itself: everything after the source's publication. "Rule / buy-and-hold": gain of the rule and of buy-and-hold on the same bars, 10 bp fee per order. Proofs SAP-9331c1d0a12b, SAP-36e1c240bcf0, SAP-a8da000c5765, SAP-a146def82f8a, SAP-079ece1b0595, SAP-27cc6789cb8f, SAP-035c6c0ee3ef, SAP-b8a2bfb937f8, SAP-a957ae453110, SAP-c10f6798067d, SAP-f5a6743b89e3, SAP-68099bf0d32a. Gaps with the source: Six FRED currencies, one at a time; without the system 1 filter or unit additions; closes only (close-to-close volatility); system 2 reuses the band opened by system 1, which the Lab counts as a reopening. Data: Ken French Data Library, FRED (Board of Governors). Research on past data, not advice; no future return is promised.

Have your own variant judged in the Lab → All verdicts

SOURCES (CHECKED)

The Original Turtle Trading Rules (Curtis Faith et al., 2003, distributed free, now at tradingblox.com/originalturtles); Faith, C., Way of the Turtle, McGraw-Hill, 2007 (ISBN 9780071486644).

← All Minds Bogle All verdicts