Skip to main content
← Back to Minds
🧭

What the Lab does not judge (yet)

Seykota, Gann, Elliott, Simons
Why some famous methods have no verdict
Pantheon: wave 2Judged by the Lab

ONE RULE, ONCE, BEFORE THE DATA

The Lab judges a rule written before seeing the data, played once and counted. What was never written that way is not "wrong": it is out of a judge's reach, and saying so is already information. Here are four famous names, what the Lab cannot judge in their work, and what it can judge instead.

ED SEYKOTA

The Market Wizards hero (Schwager, 1989) followed trends with exponential averages, but never published exact parameters. Any "Seykota strategy" is therefore someone else's choice: judging it would judge that choice, not Seykota. What the Lab can judge: the same family in a published, dated form (see Faber and the Turtles), and any variant you write yourself.

W. D. GANN

Angles, squares and dates (Truth of the Stock Tape, 1923) leave the reader to choose the starting point, scale and angle. Without those choices written in advance, two readers draw two signals from the same chart. What the Lab can judge: one precise reading, written before looking at the data; every reading tried counts as a trial.

R. N. ELLIOTT

Wave counts (The Wave Principle, 1938; Frost and Prechter, 1978) are revised when price changes: they make no dated forecast. What the Lab can judge: a wave detector written in full (pivots, thresholds, entry, exit), presented for what it is, one reading among others.

JIM SIMONS

Renaissance Technologies published no rule and no parameter (Zuckerman, The Man Who Solved the Market, 2019). What is attributed to its team, many small signals tested at scale, is precisely what forces one to count trials: that is the work of the Lab's judge (Bailey and López de Prado's deflated Sharpe, 2014; Harvey, Liu and Zhu's raised thresholds, 2016).

Write your reading and have it judged in the Lab →
← All Minds Bogle All verdicts