Skip to main content
← Back to Minds
🎃

Bouman & Jacobsen

Netherlands
Authors of "The Halloween Indicator, “Sell in May and Go Away”" (2002)
Pantheon: wave 2Judged by the Lab

THE IDEA

The "Sell in May and go away" saying as a rule: invested from early November to end of April, out from May to October.

WHAT THE THEORY REALLY PROMISES

Winter returns exceed summer returns in most countries. The paper does not promise to beat buy-and-hold after fees.

JUDGED BY THE LAB ON UNSEEN YEARS

MarketUnseen periodVerdictRule / buy-and-holdMax drawdown rule / buy-and-holdProof
Asia-Pacific ex Japan2013-09 → 2026-08 (13.0 y)No proof of an edge yet+87.4% / +107.8%37.1% / 37.2%SAP-3c3916056432
Europe2013-09 → 2026-08 (13.0 y)No proof of an edge yet+143.6% / +176.1%35.7% / 35.7%SAP-f0939b09d16c
Japan2013-09 → 2026-08 (13.0 y)No proof of an edge (Deflated Sharpe below 50%)+62.7% / +206.9%26.9% / 32.9%SAP-a4201f59d0f3
North America2013-09 → 2026-08 (13.0 y)No proof of an edge yet+101.6% / +432.0%34.9% / 34.9%SAP-1d62b118f584

What the theory brings, measured. Invested half the time (50% of days), the "winter only" rule earned +143.6% in Europe vs +176.1% for the whole year, over 13.0 unseen years. It stays below buy-and-hold in all four regions, with the widest gap in North America (+101.6% vs +432.0%). What the saying brings, measured: a large share of the rise with half the time in the market; no extra gain. Only about 13 cycles: the Lab cannot yet tell a real effect from luck.

Rule written and preregistered on 12/10/2026, before any proof, with its source's parameters; one trial per market, nothing tuned; judged in certified mode by Lab 270, which cuts the unseen period itself: everything after the source's publication. "Rule / buy-and-hold": gain of the rule and of buy-and-hold on the same bars, 10 bp fee per order. Proofs SAP-3c3916056432, SAP-f0939b09d16c, SAP-a4201f59d0f3, SAP-1d62b118f584. Gaps with the source: Ken French regional indices in dollars instead of national indices; cash at 0% in summer; about 13 cycles in the period, too few to tell a real effect from luck. Data: Ken French Data Library, FRED (Board of Governors). Research on past data, not advice; no future return is promised.

Have your own variant judged in the Lab → All verdicts

SOURCES (CHECKED)

Bouman, S., Jacobsen, B. (2002), "The Halloween Indicator, “Sell in May and Go Away”: Another Puzzle", American Economic Review 92(5), 1618-1635, DOI 10.1257/000282802762024683; Andrade, Chhaochharia, Fuerst (2013), FAJ 69(4), 94-105, DOI 10.2469/faj.v69.n4.4.

← All Minds Bogle All verdicts